There is nothing better than making cookies, whether you’re an experienced baker or just starting out. Although the final product is typically a delicious treat, the process of ensuring that all of the cookies are the same size may be time-consuming and untidy. Cookie scoops, like ice cream scoops, may help you form exactly proportioned balls of dough.
There are a wide variety of cookie scoops available to meet a variety of baking and culinary demands. If you’re searching for a scooper that can also serve as a melon baller or aid in the creation of the perfect meatball, a cookie scoop is an excellent choice.
1. Best Overall: Oxo Good Grips Medium Cookie Scoop
What We Admire
- Squeezing the handle is a breeze.
- Durable
- Different possibilities for size
What We Hate About It
- Dough may get entangled in wiper blades.
Oxo has built a reputation as a go-to brand for kitchen products that are simple, high-quality, and low-cost, and this cookie scoop is no exception. Easy to push thanks to the spring-loaded grip and stainless steel scoop. Helps even the most obstinate sticky dough be transferred to the baking sheet without the use of hands.
For 2.75-inch cookies, this medium-sized scoop may hold around 1.5 teaspoons of dough. In addition to the little scoop, which contains around 1 tablespoon of dough, this scoop is also available in two larger sizes, big holding 3 tablespoons of dough. In addition, it’s dishwasher safe, so you can spend less time cleaning and more time enjoying your wonderful cookies. Using this scoop is safe, however you should wash it beforehand to remove any dough that may have been caught between the scoop and wiper.
2. Best Budget: Wilton Stainless Steel Small Cookie Scoop
What We Admire
- Sturdy construction
- Versatile
- It’s simple to use.
What We Hate About It
- Isn’t going to be around forever.
If you’re in need of baking or culinary tools, you may want to check out Wilton, another well-known brand. To top it all off, the firm provides a choice of gorgeous and brightly colored baking decorations and containers. Small and dependable, this stainless steel cookie scoop is our top pick for a low-cost alternative. In addition to its light weight and spring-loaded handle, this tool is easy to hold and squeeze.
This cookie dough scoop has a capacity of roughly 4 teaspoons, making it ideal for making little, uniform cookies. In addition to cookies, the compact size of this scoop makes it an excellent melon baller and for producing cake pops.
Especially due to the fact that it can only be washed by hand, customers appreciate how durable and simple it is to use and clean. This cookie scraper has an internal wiper to make it easier to remove tough cookie dough without the need of hands. Despite the fact that most reviews say this scoop is a good value for the money, it may not last as long as some of the others on the list. If you’re seeking to get your feet wet with a cookie dough scoop for the first time or are on a budget, this is the scoop for you.
3. Best Set: Saebye Cookie Scoop Set
What We Admire
- Versatile
- With one hand, it is easy to squeeze.
- Fun patterns in a variety of hues.
What We Hate About It
- For scooping ice cream, this isn’t great.
If you’re a regular baker, you’ll want to have a variety of scoop sizes on available. Saebye’s versatile cookie scoops are ideal in this situation. This set of scoops may be used to bake cookies, muffins, and cupcakes of the same size, or to scoop out mashed potatoes or fruit. Although they were made for scooping softer things, it is advisable to avoid using them to scoop subzero ice cream since they may shatter.
Small, medium, and big are all included in this set of three stainless steel scoops. To avoid corrosion, the scoops are also stain-resistant. The colorful handles include an ergonomic cog-and-ratchet release mechanism, so you can squeeze the lever with little effort. According to customers who have used the scoops, they don’t leave their hands weary after scooping a large number of cookies. So, if you’re looking for a quality set of scoops at a reasonable price, this is a great option.
4. Best Small: Norpro Stainless Steel 25-Milliliter Scoop
What We Admire
- Dough comes out with ease.
- Suitable for melon balls and cake pops
- It has a smooth, slick finish.
What We Hate About It
- The internal sweeper is susceptible to being jammed.
Mini cookies, cake pops, and fruit may all be easily scooped up with a small cookie scoop. The Norpro 25-Millimeter Stainless Steel Scoop, which contains half a tablespoon of cookie dough, is our pick for the best tiny cookie scoop. The spring-action handle and high polish finish of this stainless steel scoop make it simple to remove food from the scoop with ease, even while cutting through dough and melons. Despite the fact that it may be washed in a dishwasher, the manufacturer recommends hand cleaning for best results.
This simple cookie scoop is available in four different sizes to suit a wide range of baking and culinary applications. Using a basic scoop like this one ensures that cookie dough balls are consistently shaped and that they don’t go all over the counter. Mini meatballs for Italian wedding soup may be easily made with this scoop, according to one reviewer. You can also use it to make no-fuss dog treats for your four-legged companions. There is just one drawback to this scoop: the internal sweeper may become jammed and cause it to stop scooping dough midway through the process. That said, the high quality and ample quantity of this cookie cutter will keep you busy for years to come creating delicious cookies.
5. Best Large: Gorilla Grip Premium Multi-Purpose 8-Tablespoon Stainless Steel Scoop
What We Admire
- Handle has a comfortable, ergonomic design.
- Versatile
- There are a wide range of colors and sizes available.
What We Don’t Like
- Inevitably, this means ice cream
When it comes to cookie scoops, Gorilla Grip’s Premium Multi-Purpose Stainless Steel Scoop is your best option. To produce 4.5-inch cookies, this scoop can handle 8 teaspoons of batter. Because of its size, the scoop is designed with an ergonomic soft grip and spring-loaded handle that make it easy to squeeze without tiring your hand.
Black, turquoise, hot pink, and mint are just a few of the 12 hues available for this scoop. If the 8-tablespoon scoop is too big for your requirements, there are seven different sizes to choose from. Despite its versatility, several consumers have complained that it isn’t ideal for scooping ice cream. In addition to being simple to handle and use, it is also simple to clean by hand or in the dishwasher.
6. Best With Push Button: Mrs. Fields Silicone Scoop N Cut Cookie Tool
What We Admire
- An all-in-one gadget
- Compact
- Scoops that are simple to push
What We Hate About It
- The design is inconvenient.
To be sure, Mrs. Fields has been producing cookie scoops since 1977, so you know you can rely on her to provide a high-quality product. Mrs. Field’s Scoop N Cut Cookie Tool, on the other hand, is composed of silicone and plastic, not stainless steel like the others on the list. In addition, it has a push-button design instead of a pull lever or trigger for an extra scooping option. The middle handle doubles as a cutter, allowing you to cut cookie dough into rolls with ease. Because it is not the most ergonomic scoop, this little instrument may cause your hands to get fatigued more quickly than if you were to use a lever or trigger.
This cookie cutter comes with two distinct scoop sizes: 1 teaspoon and 1 tablespoon. To remove the dough, just press the silicone scoops in and out of the molds. To prevent the scoops from sticking, it’s best to coat them with cooking spray before using. Take it out of the oven and chuck it in the dishwasher or wash it by hand.
The Bottom Line
With a wide range of sizes and a pleasant grip, the Oxo Good Grips Medium Cookie Scoop is our top pick. To save money, choose the Wilton Stainless Steel Small Cookie Scoop, which comes in two sizes: small and medium.
When Buying a Cookie Scoop, What to Consider First
A variety of cookie scoop sizes are available, so be sure to check the scoop size before making a purchase. The scooping capacity ranges from 1.5 teaspoons to 8 tablespoons, depending on the model you choose. It is possible to use little scoops to make cookies or cake pops, and they may also be used to make melon balls. For muffins, scones, and even meatballs, larger scoops are ideal.
Specify a release date
It’s crucial to evaluate how simple it is to squeeze shut most of the lever release cookie scoops on our list. Some cookie scoops have been engineered to reduce the amount of pressure required to squeeze the levers together, making them perfect for those with hand weakness.
Material
Because of its flexibility and reliability, stainless steel is a popular material for cookie scoops. Stainless steel scoops aren’t all created equal. It is possible to get stainless steel scoops, which are more durable and may be used to scoop anything from dough to ice cream without difficulty. Other scoops are protected against rust by coatings.
Affordability
If dishwasher safety is essential to you, be sure to check the manufacturer’s instructions before using a cookie scoop. Most scoops may be cleaned by hand with soap and water if they aren’t dishwasher safe.
FAQs
To release the dough, you squeeze a trigger or lever handle on most cookie scoops. Cookie dough may be scooped into a cookie dough scoop and then released onto a cookie sheet by squeezing the lever. Push-button cookie scoops are another option. Push the back of the scoop forward with this motion, and you’ll see the dough spill out.
What you need is entirely up to you. There are cookie scoops of all sizes, from little to huge, on the market today. A medium scoop is your best choice if you want to bake cookies that are roughly 2.5 to 3 inches in diameter. You may get a sense of how much dough the scoops can contain and the final cookie size by reading the manufacturer’s descriptions of the scoops.
Cookie dough tends to cling to the scoop, so what can you do?
Stainless steel cookie scoops are ideal for preventing the cookie dough from adhering to the scoop’s inside. A wiper on the inside of a cookie scoop also aids in the removal of the dough. Prevent the dough from sticking by sprinkling some nonstick cookie spray inside your scoop before you start scooping.
A lot of cookie scoops may be used for more than just scooping out cookies. If you need to scoop out mashed potatoes, you may use little scoops, but you can also use bigger scoops to get the job done. Read the manufacturer’s instructions on how and when to use your cookie scoop, since the functionality varies from brand to brand and from size to size.
